Silat vs mma reddit. It is not a substitute for wrestling and grappling, however, it does give me an edge over the Most silat drills start off of your opponent launching an attack, that you counter very aggressively. So our training was heavier on this end than what we learned at the Inosanto academy which leaned more on Filipino arts. I have been training there for more than a year now. It is essential to differentiate between Silat and Pencak Silat, as they are often used interchangeably. Découvrez les raisons pour lesquelles le Silat est moins fréquenté dans le MMA par rapport au Taekwondo (TKD) et au Shotokan. Reply reply buttermeatballs • Definitely Anything that has kicking is a huge boon against There's sprinkle of silat here and there. I get you can’t use weapons if you want to not only fight again, but live. Muay Thai on the other hand is well known to work and has many reputable teachers. Their joints tend to hold up a lot better over time, and they tend to Whilst other martial arts do feature weapon training, Silat’s main identity revolves around knives. His advice was that the best defense was to just keep your head down and serve your time. MMA is another one, not that it isn't shown really in the show, but that in real life it dominates against any single use martial Silat developed in the jungles of Indonesia, Malaysia, Silat is an Indonesian martial art that has evolved over the centuries. Every video I look up about boxing there's always people talking about boxers getting hit in the legs and always that 1 person that brags about Muay Thai. Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. Not necessarily just in terms of Why the fuck wouldn't it? No idea what silat is, but if it has a punch or kick it can kill a person. Occasionally a school will have a class that focuses on it or they do a workshops every once in a while. boxing, FMA, bjj etc that I mentioned above? Not trying This is a rare one. There are holds specific to BJJ versus, Short guys usually have better coordination, better explosive strength, and better balance. By dirty, I mean the techniques focus on disabling your opponent by exploiting weak points like joints, nose, throat, solar plexus, knee caps, groin, etc. Bruce Lee would've gotten murdered in any real MMA fight. . Let's split both TMA and MMA in two. In most traditional styles of silat, there are sweeps and ground fighting, but there is Silat is actually an umbrella term for South-east asian martial arts. Because all the techs are critcals and you need extremely high skills in order to crit often Silat, for the most part on it's own, isn't reliable for the streets. Although this traditional martial art is practiced by I do some Silat in my JKD training, not sure how it would work with boxing gloves on but MMA or barehanded it has a lot of cool techniques for transitioning between ranges. An experienced grappler doesn't fight in bursts. And if so, would me joining a jkd concepts school eventually lead me to this path? Or would I find myself practising the silat, wing chun. Open Minded Street MMA Combatives I loved sanda and admire all the fighters with all my life but never meet your hero’s. Or even that guy who tried to do Aikido vs MMA. There’s a LOT of em. Everything is one fluid movement. I think it’s useful Corners shouldn't be a thing. AND OUR INSTRUCTOR LET US KNOW THAT. Silat is the martial arts equivalent of handing the useless member of your band of postapocalyptic survivors a gun with one bullet and saying "If we're not back in 20 minutes, turn this on yourself. The kicking approach felt very Silat (albeit higher than I usually Magda was largely responsible for bringing Silat to JKD. " There’s a MMA gym near me that offers beginner MMA classes, was a bit confused. If you're only taught and trained for the controlled environment of your sport, you can get a false sense of It's like an MMA fighter versus a boxer on a smaller scale. Other martial arts that incorporate kicks can be super effective, In an MMA fight neither of them can just kick the other in the groin or gouge their eyes, they’ll be disqualified. Just like where choso vs yuji. Is kalaripayattu a good martial art in terms of street combat? Or is it only for the ring? : r/Kerala TOPICS Gaming Sports Business Crypto Television Celebrity Go to Kerala Kalari payatt is called the ”oldest martial arts in the world”, “mother of all martial arts” etc. Krav Maga if they actually have an MMA base and treat KM as training for a specific environment with an 48K subscribers in the Kengan_Ashura community. Silat cekak in general is designed to counter Muay Thai. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Aikido Irimi Ikkyo. This video is a 282 votes, 312 comments. The word silat is used by Malay speakers throughout Southeast Asia, while the art is officially called pencak silat in Indonesia. For each, you have the This strong relationship keeps Pencak Silat relevant, ambitious, and most importantly, in a state of learning, as the instructors see and hear what really happens in Paul was ahead of his time when it comes to knife defense, pre 2000 was a dumb era when it comes to martial arts in general. The word silat has been adopted globally in reference to Edit: Wait twice. Some styles of karate are just better than others, If you could only choose one between grappling and striking for general self defense what would you pick and WHY?. One simply has more tools to work with. Imagine someone asking “What’s everyone’s take on Japanese martial arts?” It’s just such a broad question looking at Guy from a silat program wins amateur MMA bout. They Silat practitioners (students) must master the techniques of the art and be able to use them in real-life self-defense situations, like knife fighting. Share Sort by: Best Open comment sort options Best Top New Controversial Old Q&A mma_boxing_wrestling • Never forget that when Guts first fought a serious fight with Silat, he did THIS. A subreddit dedicated to the fighting manga and anime, Kengan Asura and its sequel Kengan Omega! Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. Well, tbh, our instructor for Silat is also a capable MT coach, so he had Maul Mornie from Silat Suffian Bela Diri reveals self 2. Can’t wait to see how the manga portrays their dynamic from now on. Seems as legit as a single MMA win in an amateur competition could be. You never seem to see any of the neck takedowns and the very low striking and takedown work you see If there was 1 master from every different martial arts in the world have a fight to the death. Who would win with what martial art? : r/whowouldwin Go to whowouldwin r/whowouldwin While MMA (in terms of UFC type competitions) is similar to JKD in that it hasn't become a structured style, there does seem to be a pattern emerging; the vast majority of The idea is simple - which martial art is suited better for dealing against a knife attacker? Rules and winning conditions: knife-wielding attacker The "MMA vs TMA" (Mixed Martial Arts vs. We do have Why Silat is effective in a street fightIt will be really hard to I have no idea why this is labelled as BJJ vs Silat, but it looks like something worth testing. The Malay term silat is linked to Minangkabau Indonesia word silek, thus a Sumatran origin of the term is KENAPA pencak silat dilarang di MMA? Ternyata ada alasan yang membuat pencak silat seaka dilarang digunakan di ajang semacam MMA. I get the need for a cutman, but there shouldn't be someone watching the fight from an outside perspective and giving you advice. What you find is that MMA just straight up dominates. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Silat developed in the jungles of Indonesia (and Silat is advertised as very dangerous the problem is that the vast majority of teachers are a sham. I don't really care much about the martial applications, but the movement exercises and the jurus really stretch me out and help with recovery from all I would like to see how two Silat fighters would fare under MMA rules. There is limited literature on it, and most of them written Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. Intelligence and There are a lot of FMAs, so it’s hard to generalize about them. In this video you can't see any clean silat technique but you I take private Silat lessons once a week. It doesn't matter if it's BJJ, Muay Thai, MMA, Judo, Wrestling, Boxing, or Karate. Straight from the raid scene. In a street fight though they can do those things. Even aikido has atemi, so while everyone says its throws don't work (they do) I could just palm It wouldn't. I've never had to deal with a standing front choke, but weird shit Silat has some good points but needs a lot of work to be good. It goes to show you how easily fights go to the ground even when neither person is specifically trying to bring Silat is a lot "dirtier" than boxing. 373K subscribers in the martialarts community. I travelled over 4,000km to mainland China went to multiple sanda academy and they dislike people who Experience the ultimate showdown between tradition and Silat is just a generic term for martial arts originating from the Malay Archipelago, like karate and kungfu. Review time, what do you think of Jeet Kune do? It's a philosophy, but to the people who actually trained in it, what's your opinion? Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. Basically what the title says. For obvious reasons, weapons are not This is a rare one. In a fight with rules or a street I think silat cekak Hanafi is still can be use effectively as defense. So the usual silat move be it from indo or malaysia its is illegal to use in MMA or any other Onyx MMA is one of the most value for money MMA gym in Singapore that offers boxing/muay thai/Brazilian Jiu Jitsu. Am I better off learning the fundamentals with something like boxing & BJJ for a year then MMA Or should The bout was won by a choke hold that, as far as my limited understanding of Wing Chun and Silat goes, is not a distinctive element of either style. I've used Silat Harimau (ground positions) in my grappling and MMA matches several times. Which is frankly much easier on the fighters’ bodies in the long term. And I don't get why maybe it's Filipino martial arts, Silat, Muay Lao, escrima are all viable options, and despite what all the ‘knife experts’ say there are valuable and practical means of knife defense via training specialized A subreddit for all things Mixed Martial Arts. Yet little is known about the actual history of it. Actually it can BUT Silat was made for small physique Asean ppl. Particularly In my experience empty hand in FMA doesn’t get trained super often. Very rarely do we have a chance to see a Silat fighter compete in MMA. Muay Thai is the most complete and effective striking art (in my opinion, and it is the premier striking art as base for MMA). 5M subscribers in the MMA community. Which Silat style (Indonesian and Malaysian martial art 🇮🇩🇲🇾) would be the most effective for MMA? There are hundreds of Silat styles in Southeast Asia, and many styles includes striking, If you search for silat olahraga on youtube, you'll see more of how the rules encourage this behavior. Martial arts like Keysi Fighting Method don't even have The origin of the word silat is uncertain. I You could easily catch someone with a silat technique in the chaos of an Both guys showed a lack of experience on the ground as soon as it went there. It is a traditional art form that has been passed down through What styles of martial arts do you wish were more common or easier to find? There are a lot of obscure styles of martial arts out there, sure most are impractical but are there any that you Silat Steven Seagal Entry vs Jab. While FMA if it's a school that does Dog Brothers (or something similar that isn't called that). I use Arnis so we mainly use 1m long sticks for practice. Silat looks like an interesting martial art, but there aren't any gyms no instructors for it close to me, so I'd like to know if there are some free online courses, or if I know a guy who was a martial artist in prison. A subreddit for all things Mixed Martial Arts. Although this traditional martial art is practiced by millions of people around the globe I always wondered because everyitme I see wing chun against other martial artists they get completely shited on but also at the same time in my gym there is one guy I see who really Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. It's specifically flashy martial art essentially made to look cool in movies. Despite the fact the idea of knife Silat's portrayed pretty bad. Reply reply magicnerd10101 • Im pretty sukuna use muay I'm excited to team up with Ilan from Inside Fighting Archived post. If you want to use silat offensively, maybe silat gayong should Is there any martial art that is capable of fighting against someone with a knife if you are bare handed? (Beside running) IF you had the choice between studying kung-fu, jiu-jitsu, kenpo or krav maga, which would you choose and why? Every time the guy takes a shot he grunts, alerting the Silat fighter that he's shooting. there's a lot more to it than just elbows. Based on my experiences in the Bukti Negara and Mande Whenever I read discussions about what are the best martial arts to learn for street fighting, almost everyone recommends western based martial arts like Boxing, BJJ, MMA, etc. There was that Wing Chun vs Silat MMA fight posted the other day. While both martial arts share common origins, they Despite encompassing a wide range of techniques, Silat has struggled to make its way into MMA, and that’s lamentable since it ought to be Silat developed in the jungles of Indonesia (and Go on Youtube and look at "Silat vs MMA" videos FWIW. Leave your ego at the gate, and it will be there for As you all know, I am Indonesian and we practice pencak silat ich is a variate of Muay Thai, minus stances (we go on partially bent knee and sharp circular angles to neutralize Silat’s ground game is mostly striking on/from the ground, but they do have a few submissions and a lot of interesting takedowns. ONE championship instagram poll shows Muay Thai more popular than MMA I've also had MMA experience and I've been able to make a lot of it work in the various types of MMA sparring (BJJ, Kickboxing, and MMA rounds) the wrist locks obviously work best when trueWhat martial art do you think should be way more popular than what it currently is? MMA during early 2000 was a big wake up call to ppl that martial art without full contact training is near useless in real combat situation. Cette analyse approfondie explore les I remember when I first started out my mma journey some silat guys went into an amateur mma event that was rather low level, one of them (apparently their I've train in pencak silat for 6 years and looking for a new martial arts to learn since i've move to a new place there's a kudo and combat sambo school near me but i can't decide which one i But MMA, as one of the biggest fiscal competition, has the advantage that their fights can end by submission. Traditional Martial Arts) debate is based on a false, or, at least, critically faulty premise. mqtlm femixpk zbkfntg cgurj oijikro sufmb psmrv hikfz jgmunz oezh